1840 & Company official logo

14 Ways to Improve Your Diversity Recruiting Strategy

Your guide on optimizing diversity recruiting: from foundational principles to technological tools, uncover the path to an inclusive hiring strategy.
Diversity recruiting strategies



In the modern business landscape, diversity is more than just a buzzword—it’s a critical component of a thriving, innovative, and competitive organization. As companies strive to reflect the diverse world in which they operate, the role of recruiting in fostering workplace diversity has never been more paramount. In this article, we aim to provide a comprehensive guide on enhancing diversity recruiting strategies, emphasizing the importance of building a more inclusive workforce and the tangible benefits it brings.

The Current Landscape of Diversity Recruiting

A Snapshot of Diversity Recruiting

Diversity recruiting, at its core, is the practice of hiring candidates from a variety of backgrounds, experiences, and perspectives. It goes beyond the traditional parameters of age, gender, and ethnicity, encompassing factors like socio-economic background, education, cognitive diversity, and more.

The Tangible Benefits of a Diverse Workforce

Research consistently underscores the myriad benefits of a diverse workforce:

  • Innovation: Diverse teams bring a plethora of perspectives, leading to more creative solutions and products.
  • Better Decision-Making: A study by Cloverpop found that diverse teams make decisions 60% faster than non-diverse teams.
  • Increased Profitability: According to McKinsey, companies with diverse executive teams are 33% more likely to outperform their peers in profitability.

Common Misconceptions About Diversity Recruiting

While the importance of diversity is widely acknowledged, misconceptions persist. Some view it as a mere box-ticking exercise or a PR move. In reality, diversity recruiting is about tapping into a vast pool of talent, ensuring that the best candidates are not overlooked due to biases or outdated practices.

Challenges in Diversity Recruiting

The Pervasive Issue of Unconscious Bias

Even with the best intentions, unconscious biases can creep into the recruitment process. These are deep-seated prejudices we may not be aware of, influencing our perception of candidates. For instance, this study found that resumes with traditionally “white-sounding” names received 50% more callbacks than identical resumes with “African-American sounding” names.

The Misconception of Diversity as a ‘Quota’

Some organizations approach diversity recruiting with a quota mindset, aiming to fill specific numbers rather than genuinely fostering inclusivity. This not only undermines the true essence of diversity but can also lead to resentment among employees.

Sourcing Diverse Candidates

A significant challenge many recruiters face is the lack of diverse candidates in the recruitment pipeline. Traditional sourcing methods might not reach a broad spectrum of candidates, leading to a homogenous applicant pool.

Overcoming Outdated Recruiting Practices

Many companies still rely on outdated recruiting practices that don’t prioritize diversity. Whether it’s using non-inclusive language in job descriptions or not leveraging diverse job boards, these practices can stymie efforts to build a diverse workforce.

Women interviewing for a job position

The Cornerstones of Effective Diversity Recruiting

Diversity recruiting is not just about sourcing candidates from different backgrounds; it’s about creating a holistic strategy that integrates diversity into every facet of the hiring process. To truly champion diversity, companies must build their recruiting strategies on a foundation of key principles. Here are the cornerstones that underpin effective diversity recruiting:

Understanding the Why: The Business Case for Diversity

Before diving into the tactics of diversity recruiting, it’s crucial to understand its strategic importance. A diverse workforce isn’t just a moral imperative; it’s a business one. Diverse teams bring a range of perspectives, fostering creativity, innovation, and better problem-solving. Moreover, companies that prioritize diversity are better positioned to understand and serve their diverse customer base, leading to improved market reach and profitability.

Commitment from the Top: The Role of Leadership

The commitment to diversity must start at the top. Leaders play a pivotal role in setting the tone for the organization. When senior executives champion diversity, it sends a clear message about the company’s values and priorities. Leaders should not only talk the talk but walk the walk—by participating in diversity training, setting clear diversity goals, and holding themselves accountable for achieving them.

Inclusive Company Culture: Making Diversity a Part of the Company’s DNA

Diversity recruiting doesn’t end once a candidate is hired. To retain diverse talent, companies must foster an inclusive culture where all employees feel valued and heard. This involves:

  • Open Dialogue: Encouraging discussions about diversity and inclusion, allowing employees to share their experiences and insights.
  • Diversity Training: Offering regular training sessions to educate employees about the importance of diversity and how to foster it.
  • Employee Resource Groups: Creating groups where employees from similar backgrounds can connect, share, and support each other.

Continuous Evaluation and Improvement

The landscape of diversity and inclusion is ever-evolving. What worked a few years ago might not be effective today. Companies must continuously evaluate their diversity recruiting strategies, gathering feedback, analyzing results, and making necessary adjustments. This iterative approach ensures that the strategy remains relevant and effective.

Transparency and Accountability

For diversity recruiting to be effective, it must be transparent. Companies should be open about their diversity goals, the strategies they’re employing, and the results they’re achieving. This transparency builds trust, both internally among employees and externally among candidates and the broader public. Moreover, with clear metrics and regular reporting, companies can hold themselves accountable, ensuring that they stay on track to achieve their diversity objectives.

Sorting through resume for inclusive hiring

14 Diversity Recruiting Strategies to Enhance Inclusive Hiring

To effectively champion diversity in the recruitment process, companies must employ a multifaceted approach. While understanding the foundational principles is crucial, it’s equally important to have actionable strategies in place. Here are seven proven strategies that can significantly enhance diversity recruiting efforts:

1. Unconscious Bias Training

What it is: A program designed to help recruiters and hiring managers recognize and address their inherent biases that might influence their perception of candidates.

Why it’s essential: Everyone has biases, often formed by societal influences and personal experiences. By recognizing these biases, recruiters can make more objective and fair hiring decisions.

Implementation Tips:

  • Offer regular training sessions for all employees involved in the hiring process.
  • Use real-world examples to highlight common biases and their impact.
  • Encourage open discussions where employees can share their experiences and learn from each other.

2. Diverse Interview Panels

What it is: An interviewing approach where candidates are interviewed by a panel comprising individuals from varied backgrounds and departments.

Why it’s essential: A diverse panel can provide multiple perspectives, reducing the chances of biases influencing the hiring decision.

Implementation Tips:

  • Ensure that the panel represents a mix of genders, ethnicities, and professional backgrounds.
  • Train panel members on the importance of diversity and how to conduct unbiased interviews.

3. Targeted Outreach

What it is: Building relationships with organizations, institutions, and platforms that cater to underrepresented groups.

Why it’s essential: It allows companies to tap into a broader talent pool, ensuring they don’t miss out on qualified candidates due to limited outreach.

Implementation Tips:

  • Partner with colleges, universities, and organizations that have a strong focus on diversity.
  • Attend diversity-focused job fairs and events.
  • Advertise job openings on platforms known for their diverse user base.

4. Inclusive Job Descriptions

What it is: Crafting job ads that are free from gendered language or specific cultural references, ensuring they appeal to a broad audience.

Why it’s essential: The language used in job descriptions can either attract or deter potential candidates. Inclusive language ensures that no one feels excluded.

Implementation Tips:

  • Use tools that analyze job descriptions for biased language.
  • Highlight the company’s commitment to diversity and inclusion in the job ad.
  • Avoid using jargon or industry-specific terms that might not be universally understood.

5. Data-Driven Decisions

What it is: Leveraging analytics and data to track, measure, and refine diversity recruiting efforts.

Why it’s essential: Data provides objective insights, allowing companies to understand where they’re succeeding and where there’s room for improvement.

Implementation Tips:

  • Use analytics tools to track the diversity of applicants, interviewees, and hires.
  • Regularly review data to identify trends and patterns.
  • Adjust strategies based on data-driven insights.

6. Employee Resource Groups (ERGs)

What it is: Internal groups where employees from similar backgrounds or interests can connect, share experiences, and support each other.

Why it’s essential: ERGs provide a sense of community, helping retain diverse talent and offering insights into how to attract similar candidates.

Implementation Tips:

  • Support the formation of ERGs within the company.
  • Encourage cross-collaboration between different ERGs.
  • Leverage ERGs for feedback on recruiting strategies and company culture.

7. Mentorship Programs

What it is: Programs where experienced employees offer guidance, support, and advice to newer or potential candidates from diverse backgrounds.

Why it’s essential: Mentorship provides candidates with a clearer path to success within the company, making the organization more attractive to diverse talent.

Implementation Tips:

  • Pair mentors and mentees based on professional goals rather than just demographic similarities.
  • Offer training for mentors to ensure they provide valuable guidance.
  • Regularly gather feedback from participants to refine the program.

8. Transparency in Hiring Processes

What it is: Clearly communicating the steps, criteria, and expectations during the hiring process.

Why it’s essential: Transparency ensures that all candidates, regardless of their background, have a clear understanding of what’s expected, reducing potential biases or misunderstandings.

Implementation Tips:

  • Provide candidates with a detailed overview of the interview process.
  • Offer feedback to candidates post-interview, regardless of the outcome.
  • Regularly review and update hiring criteria to ensure they remain relevant and unbiased.

9. Flexible Work Arrangements

What it is: Offering options like remote work, flexible hours, or part-time positions.

Why it’s essential: Different candidates have varied needs and lifestyles. Flexibility can make a position more attractive to a broader range of potential employees.

Implementation Tips:

  • Survey current employees to understand their preferences and needs.
  • Ensure that flexible work arrangements don’t lead to any form of discrimination or bias.
  • Regularly review and adjust policies based on feedback and changing circumstances.

10. Diversity-Focused Job Fairs

What it is: Participating in or hosting job fairs that prioritize diversity.

Why it’s essential: These events provide direct access to a diverse pool of potential candidates, ensuring a broader reach.

Implementation Tips:

  • Research and identify relevant diversity-focused job fairs in your industry or region.
  • Ensure that your company’s representatives at these events reflect its commitment to diversity.
  • Engage with potential candidates, offering insights into the company’s culture and values.

11. Feedback Mechanisms

What it is: Systems that allow candidates to provide feedback on their experience during the recruiting process.

Why it’s essential: Feedback offers insights into areas of improvement, ensuring that the recruiting process remains candidate-friendly and unbiased.

Implementation Tips:

  • Offer anonymous feedback options to ensure candid responses.
  • Regularly review feedback and implement necessary changes.
  • Engage with candidates who had both positive and negative experiences to gain a comprehensive understanding.

12. Continuous Learning

What it is: Keeping updated with the latest trends, research, and best practices in diversity and inclusion.

Why it’s essential: The landscape of diversity recruiting is ever-evolving. Staying informed ensures that strategies remain relevant and effective.

Implementation Tips:

  • Encourage recruiters and HR professionals to attend workshops, webinars, and conferences.
  • Subscribe to relevant publications or platforms that offer insights into diversity recruiting.
  • Foster a culture of continuous learning within the HR and recruiting teams.

13. Cultural Competency Training

What it is: Educating teams about various cultures, backgrounds, and experiences to foster understanding and reduce biases.

Why it’s essential: A deeper understanding of different cultures ensures respectful and effective communication with candidates from diverse backgrounds.

Implementation Tips:

  • Offer regular training sessions that delve into different cultures and their nuances.
  • Encourage open discussions where employees can share their experiences and learn from each other.
  • Provide resources for employees to explore and learn on their own.

14. Promotion of Internal Talent

What it is: Recognizing and promoting diverse talent within the organization.

Why it’s essential: Internal promotions not only retain talent but also showcase the company’s genuine commitment to diversity.

Implementation Tips:

  • Implement a transparent and fair performance review system.
  • Encourage diverse employees to take on leadership roles or participate in decision-making processes.
  • Celebrate and highlight internal success stories to inspire others.

Using technology in recruiting

Leveraging Technology in Diversity Recruiting

In the digital age, technology has become a pivotal ally in enhancing the recruitment process. For diversity recruiting, the right technological tools can significantly amplify efforts, ensuring they are efficient, scalable, and impactful.

The Role of AI and Machine Learning

Artificial Intelligence (AI) and machine learning offer the potential to revolutionize the recruitment landscape. These advanced algorithms can sift through vast amounts of data, identifying patterns and making objective decisions. By using AI-driven tools, companies can screen resumes with reduced human biases, ensuring a more equitable selection process. Furthermore, machine learning can be employed to analyze recruitment data, pinpointing trends and suggesting areas for improvement. However, it’s crucial to ensure that these AI tools are periodically audited to guarantee they operate without inherent biases.

Platforms Specializing in Sourcing Diverse Talent

There’s a growing number of online platforms and job boards dedicated to connecting employers with diverse candidates. Engaging with these platforms provides companies with a direct line to a broader and more diverse talent pool. Active participation, beyond just posting job vacancies, can also enhance a company’s reputation within these communities. It’s essential that job postings on these platforms genuinely reflect the organization’s commitment to diversity to attract the right candidates.

The Power of Analytics in Refining the Recruiting Process

Data has always been a powerful tool for decision-making, and this holds true in the realm of recruitment. Analytics tools can provide invaluable insights into the diversity of applicants, the effectiveness of various recruitment channels, and the overall success of diversity initiatives. By continuously monitoring and analyzing this data, companies can make informed decisions, tweaking their strategies for better results and ensuring that their recruitment processes remain aligned with their diversity goals.

Final Thoughts

In today’s globalized world, diversity is not just a moral imperative but a business necessity. Companies that prioritize and effectively implement diversity recruiting strategies stand to benefit from a broader range of perspectives, fostering innovation, enhancing decision-making, and ultimately driving greater success. The strategies and tools discussed here in this article provide a roadmap for organizations to enhance their diversity recruiting efforts, ensuring they attract, hire, and retain the best talent from all backgrounds.

As the business landscape continues to evolve, so too will the challenges and opportunities associated with diversity recruiting. Continuous learning, adaptation, and a genuine commitment to inclusivity will be key to navigating these changes successfully.

For organizations seeking guidance in this journey, schedule a call with our growth experts. Our deep expertise in global talent strategy and organizational development, can be a valuable partner.

In conclusion, diversity recruiting is an ongoing journey, one that requires dedication, effort, and the right strategies. But the rewards—a vibrant, inclusive, and high-performing workforce—are well worth the investment.


Ready to expand globally?

Hire Global, Vetted Talent & Teams with 1840

More Posts About

Workforce Management